Paiute protesters blocked from NV Energy's Greenlink construction site in rural Nevada

Posted

YERINGTON — NV Energy won a preliminary injunction Friday barring three prominent Native American protesters from blocking construction of the electric utility's Greenlink West transmission line northwest of Yerington, where tribal members have camped since late September to protect what they say are burial and cultural sites. 

The order covers Joshua "Numu" Dini Sr., a Walker River Paiute member whose group, Prayer Horse Inc., helped lead the protest camp. The others were Vernon Rogers, a cultural specialist for the Yerington Paiute Tribe, and tribal council member Elwood Emm Jr. — the two men Dini named while testifying. NV Energy sued Dini on Nov. 10, four days after he said his group had left the camp.

Lyon County District Judge Leon Aberasturi said he respects the prayers at the site but they interfere with NV Energy's legal right to build there. He also said he can't second-guess the Bureau of Land Management's (BLM) approval of the project. He pointed to safety, too. 

"You shouldn't have people near construction equipment," he said.

NV Energy must post a $25,000 bond, which Aberasturi said would cover costs if his ruling is later overturned, likely in federal court. The utility company, which did not immediately respond to a request for comment, will draft the order, and both sides will file more arguments on how precisely it should mark where the three men can't go. Aberasturi said he hopes to finalize the order before Dec. 15, ahead of his Jan. 4 retirement, and he urged both sides to try mediation. 

NV Energy says Dini and others are trespassing on a strip of land where it is building Greenlink West, its transmission line running from Las Vegas through Yerington to the Reno area. The utility's attorney, Adam Hosmer-Henner of the law firm McDonald Carano, called the request "extremely limited," saying it would only stop people from blocking construction. He said NV Energy had tried for months to negotiate with the protesters without success.

NV Energy's only witness, Matthew Johns, the company's vice president for environmental services and land management, testified that protesters first approached crews around Sept. 29 and asked them to stop for a seven-day ceremony, and the contractor paused work at that spot. Less than a week later, on Oct. 5, the BLM notified the tribal members that crews had made three "unanticipated discoveries" during construction.

After the ceremony, Johns said everything at the site was to stay as it was until an Oct. 14 meeting with the Yerington Paiute Tribe, BLM and NV Energy. Protesters did not leave after the meeting, he said, and between Oct. 22 and 27 they approached crews working nearby, stopping work there. Johns visited the camp Oct. 30 to arrange for removing equipment, and crews moved it on Nov. 2. 

In an Oct. 31 text message to The Nevada Independent, Dini described the meeting as a sunrise ceremony and discussion around a sacred fire that ended in an agreement.

Johns also testified that BLM has separately paused work at two spots in Lyon County, including the area next to the camp, while it reviews possible cultural discoveries. Aberasturi questioned how NV Energy could blame the protest for delays there. 

"How do you prove it's their activity versus you having BLM telling you to do other things before you start work?" he asked.

NV Energy's attorney acknowledged that construction can't move forward in the paused areas until BLM finishes its review. But he said protesters have threatened to keep protesting along the entire route indefinitely.

Steve Evenson, Dini's attorney, appeared by Zoom after being hired the night before. He initially asked to move the hearing to next week, saying it was hard to find a lawyer on short notice to face a client with "quite literally a bottomless pit of money." Aberasturi denied the request, saying he could have granted the order without a hearing based on NV Energy's sworn statements.

Under cross-examination, Johns said he couldn't put a dollar figure on the harm the protest has caused, such as idle equipment and crews, and that NV Energy has not called law enforcement on the protesters. 

Evenson argued the lawsuit looks like a SLAPP, a lawsuit meant to silence public participation, and an unconstitutional prior restraint on protest. He also noted that NV Energy's written request would bar Dini and the others named from all of the company's right-of-way land, which he argued isn't clearly defined, and make the ban permanent.

Evenson suggested that the power company came to court instead of asking the protesters to leave or calling police because "they don't want the bad PR hit." Hosmer-Henner argued BLM and state regulators had already decided the project is in the public interest, and that protesters can't take matters into their own hands.

Dini's face showed deep disappointment as he walked out of the courtroom. He said he was upset.

"They are removing us from these lands," he said. "We came up in a prayer."

He acknowledged that some protesters may have used strong words with crews, but said there was never any violence at the site.

Dini said he will follow the order but that his group needs to respond. He said other attorneys have offered to represent the group, but NV Energy moved so fast there wasn't time to bring one on before Friday's hearing. He didn't rule out taking the fight to federal court.

"We're fighting against a huge corporation that has money," he said.

He declined to say whether his group plans to file its own lawsuit. He said Rogers and Emm may be in a stronger position to bring one on the tribe's behalf.

Even if they can't be on the land, Dini said the order won't change what the camp has meant or stop them from praying for it.

"The camp is always going to be there in our hearts," he said.

Energy, Tribal Nations, Adam Hosmer-Henner, Elwood Emm Jr., Exclusive, Joshua "Numu" Dini Sr., Leon Aberasturi, Matthew Johns, mcdonald carano, NV Energy, Steve Evenson, Vernon Rogers, Yerington Paiute Tribe